Update 13 November 2015: questions remain about the proportion of profits going to charity, though MSF Sweden has confirmed there is a ‘collaboration’.
Update 10 November 2015: Fairfax columnist Ian Warden has been advised by perfume blogger Jessica that the information about Byredo donating part of its profits to MSF Sweden was on Byredo’s Facebook page. Sure enough, there it is, buried in a response to ‘Angel Blak’ on 21 September: ‘part of Rose of No Man’s Land’s global profits will be donated to Doctors without Borders (Sweden)’. We would still like to know what proportion of profits is being donated. And why not trumpet the fact?
Update 9 November 2015: we have heard nothing from either Byredo or MSF about the claim that the former is donating to the latter a proportion of the profits from flogging Rose of No Man’s Land perfume at $A200 and $A300 a bottle. We will put it down as an unconfirmed rumour.
Update 3 November 2015: Fairfax columnist Ian Warden is also chasing Byredo for answers.
Update 1 November 2015: we try to find out whether Byredo are donating some of their profits to the Swedish division of Medecins sans Frontieres.
BBC recently visited a number of No Man’s Lands, and found that in one such location in Verdun, France, a location of many horrific battles in World War I was still, 100 years later, deemed too dangerous for people to return to live, filled with unexploded ordnance, arsenic, chlorine and phosgene. Not the most appealing smell for a hip new fragrance.
Update 26 October 2015: this issue has been taken up by Fairfax columnist Ian Warden (Gang-Gang). If readers wish to make a point to the manufacturers, the email address is firstname.lastname@example.org. No Glory in War website in London reprinted our original piece.
We thought we had become immune to the crassness of Great War centenary marketing – Woolworths, Raise-a-Glass, Camp Gallipoli, Lone Pine commemorative coasters, Audacity, Anzac Ted, soft porn commemorative t-shirts, on and on it goes – but this latest one possibly takes the biscuit. It comes from Sweden and it is coming to a body near you.
Wallpaper website announces that Byredo, ‘the painfully cool Swedish fragrance brand’, is bringing out a new fragrance called ‘Rose of No Man’s Land’ to mark the centenary of World War I. This pungent unguent, says Byredo, is a ‘fragrant tribute to the nurses (often referred to by soldiers as “rose of no-man’s land”) who saved thousands of lives on the front lines’.
We are promised ‘a rose fragrance, but a clean, modern, pared-down rose rather than a blowsy old-fashioned one’. In the mix there is Turkish rose, pink pepper and papyrus. It’s described as ‘a unisex scent’ though Wallpaper‘s scribe, obviously a man’s man, suggests ‘it’s probably too floral to appeal to most men, lacking, say, the woodiness that gives Serge Lutens’ wonderful Feminité du Bois its universal appeal. But for anyone who likes a fresh floral fragrance it would be an appealing daytime choice.’
Carolyn Holbrook, author of Anzac: The Unauthorised Biography, is unconvinced. ‘I wonder what it smells of – rotting human bodies (the most potent scent in no man’s land), open latrines, cordite?’ Holbrook describes Rose of No Man’s Land as the ‘latest and arguably most distasteful example of the exploitation of human tragedy for profit’. Holbrook is one of Honest History’s distinguished supporters.
The name of this ‘trench pong’ is, of course, taken from a famous Great War song, The Rose of No Man’s Land, which will probably bring a tear to your eye. We express no opinion on what the scent of the same name will do for its users. We hope it gives them warts.
22 October 2015