Update 7 December 2017: Returned soldiers speak out against conscription, 1917; Long Tan Cross repatriation a good time to put Vietnam War in context
A manifesto printed in the Woman Voter, 6 December 1917, from returned men opposing conscription. Among other points made, they proposed conscription of wealth.
The repatriation of the Long Tan Cross from Vietnam should remind us of the many dimensions of the Vietnam War. As Douglas Newton said recently in the Great War context, there should be more to commemoration than running ‘again and again a kind of national “show-reel” of battle honours’.
Update 30 November 2017: Centenaries worth commemorating. National History Challenge. Arms and the Memorial. Counting the cost of commemoration. Happy Birthday, Winston!
Centenaries worth commemorating
Douglas Newton writes about some centenaries falling about now. They are about moves for peace during World War I. News about them was suppressed in Australia at the time and they are not getting much of a run a century on. Newton suggests we in Australia ‘are treating the centenary of the Great War as a chance to run again and again a kind of national “show-reel” of battle honours’.
Lord Lansdowne, Downing Street, 1916 (Inews)
National History Challenge
Minister Tehan has announced that Huda Mustafa Zaidi, a Year 7 student from Perth Modern School, has won the ‘Australian Wartime Experiences’ special category award in the National History Challenge for her presentation on Australia’s involvement in the Vietnam War. She was also Year 7 Western Australia Young Historian of the Year.
‘The Judges noted that Huda had taken the theme – Making a better world? – and applied it to a controversial topic with great sensitivity’, the Minister said. ‘She demonstrated a mature awareness of the research process to produce her model, presenting a well-balanced, well-referenced account of Australia’s involvement in the Vietnam War … The NHC encourages school children across the country to learn more about Australia’s past, including the significance of military history in our society.’
Director Nelson presents an Australian War Memorial Fellowship to Dennis Muilenburg, President and CEO of Boeing (Annual Report 2015-16)
Arms and the Memorial
Elsewhere we have noted the continuing infatuation of the Australian War Memorial with obtaining donations from companies we have heard referred to by senior retired service people as ‘gunrunners’. The top five international arms companies by value of sales are well represented in the Memorial’s list of donors but a change in format in the Memorial’s Annual Report means we cannot work out how much each of these companies have chipped in. A salutary read, nevertheless.
Counting the cost of commemoration
A favourite quote of ours from historian and writer, Don Watson, runs thus: ‘That’s the thing about spin – or what goes under the banner today of “communications” – you begin to believe your own bullshit’ (‘Enemy within: American politics in the time of Trump’, Quarterly Essay, no. 63, 2016, p. 61). This piece looks at some spin from the Department of Veterans’ Affairs.
Happy Birthday, Winston!
Today, 30 November, is not just the day of St Andrew, the Patron Saint of Scotland (whose lucky numbers are 53 and 24), but also the birthday of Sir Winston Churchill, who would have been 143 today – and who eventually got his fingers round the right way.